Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Blame it on the rain-doctor?

In Indonesia, rain-doctors have managed to stand the test of time--partly due to a serious mispricing in their pay-system.

Recently an important and expensive outdoor event I attended was ruined by the rain. The band, food and drinks already paid for, all went to waste as water poured down relentlessly.

It was clearly the organizer's fault. After all, rain had come down every afternoon in the three days prior to the event. And weather forecasts on the internet clearly said it was going to rain that day. But the show went on anyway without adequate precautions, and a lot of money went down the drain.

What surprised me was that most of the people I spoke to were very permissive of the screw-up. One of my friends didn't blame the organizer, but pointed the finger at the pawang-hujan/dukun or rain-doctor. She said the doctor wasn’t powerful enough.

At first I thought she was joking, thus I asked her if she really thought rain-doctors are still relevant in this 21st century. Surprisingly she defended the myth with vigor, as if defending a religion.

Okay, of course people are free to choose whatever they do or do not believe. And I respect that. But personally, I think that as modern day individuals, we should never believe in something without at least questioning it and trying to explain it with simple logic.

So I put on a provocative status update on facebook, and gathered dozens of responses from my friends about this rain doctor myth. Unsurprisingly, many were from die-hard believers.

My question was simple: If rain-doctors really exist, how come Indonesia still has droughts in poor harvests many regions? Why has the government been wasting money building irrigation systems knowing it could simply hire rain-doctors to do the job?

One friend of mine answered that there's a limitation to how far rain-doctors can make the clouds travel.

But that didn't make sense to me. Rain-doctors supposedly have powers to command ghosts/spirits that aren't constrained by the laws of nature. Here one believes in rain-doctors, yet say that the ghosts can get tired from walking too much just like us humans? Frankly, to me that just doesn't add up.

Another friend of mine told me about a 3-hour rule: rain-doctors are only able to delay the rain for 3-hours. So ghosts not only have distance constraints, but also working-hour constraints. Maybe ghosts don't like to work overtime... which also doesn't make sense.

I said in my opinion, the only reason there’s a 3-hour rule is probably because most outdoor events last 2-3 hours. If the dukuns had set a 24-hour rule, the probability of rain occurring within such a longer time frame is substantially higher. They would hence risk their reputation and people may stop believing in the myth if too many failures occur.

Meanwhile if they had set a half-hour rule, event organizers would see little use in hiring rain-doctors given that most events last 2 - 3 hours. The pawangs would then be out of the job, and the myth would disappear.

Another friend said: If rain-doctors were a hoax, how come they’ve managed to remain part of our culture for hundreds of years?

Well in my opinion this is due to at least two reasons. Firstly, hiring dukuns have become a tradition and this strengthens the demand side for rain-doctors. Secondly, there isn't a proper reward-punishment scheme for rain-doctors and this strengthens the supply side.

Indonesian culture is full of mysticism (just turn on the TV and you'll see). In case an event is messed up by rain, society blames the event organizer (EO) for not hiring a rain-doctor, not for failing to google the weather forecast and take necessary precautions.

Like the EO whose gig got ruined by the rain, his friends and employer would have directly blamed him had he not hired a dukun. So for an EO it's always nice to have a rain-doctor by his side, to make as a scapegoat in case it rains.

Meanwhile on the supply side, there will always be plenty of rain-doctors for hire. Anyone can be a rain-doctor as long as he can convince enough people that he possesses heavenly powers.

Why’s that? Because the remuneration system for rain-doctors is faulty. If it doesn’t rain, the rain-doctor gets paid in full; and if it does rain the rain-doctor gets paid little. So like a coin toss: heads I win, tails you lose! Who wouldn’t want a pay-scheme like that?

In my opinion, a rain-doctor’s pay scheme should be like a futures contract. If it doesn’t rain the doctor gets Rp2 million, but if it does rain he has to pay an equivocal penalty.

Better yet, it should be like purchasing an insurance or CDS contract. The EO pays the doctor Rp2 million, but if it rains the doctor pays a Rp100 million penalty to compensate damages! More likely than not, if such proper pay-schemes applied, the number of people who dare to take up the doctor's job would diminish fast, and the myth would be history in less than a month.

Again, people are free to choose what to and what not to believe. I’m not asking anyone to change their beliefs. Maybe someone out there has clever counter-arguments to all the points I’ve raised here... and that’s fine. May aim in writing this article is to make sure that if we do believe, we have a strong reason to do so.


Disclaimer: The views and writings posted in this site is provided as general information only and should not be taken as investment advice. They are solely the opinions of the author and do not represent the opinions of firms affiliated with the author.

24 comments:

anginpetang said...

and, pak helmi susanto,do you have strong reason for pergi jumatan, komat-kamit pake bahasa arab (kuno), naik turun, tunggak-tunggik seperti SKJ?

do you have strong reason to believe kalau nenek moyang sampeyan tercipta dari segumpal tanah, dan satu lagi tercipta dari tulang rusuk...what is your reason to believe?

nggak masalah kalau pak helmi percaya tuhan, alloh, etc. but, it would be nice if you have strong reason for it, not just because others do it, your parents inherit it to you, etc.

if you cant find any strong reason, why not stop wasting your time going for jumatan, misalnya. unless you do it just for fun or part of social activities.

salam.

ElroyTLanphear said...

好文不寂寞..................................................

LICK ME said...

Every dog has his day. ....................................................

九份 said...

看到你的好文章真是開心 加油囉.......................................

Helmi Arman said...

Angin petang, it is interesting how you analogize rain doctors with religion.

My religion was taught to me by my parents since I was little. As time progresses, I get older, I go to school and I pro-actively second guess everything that was taught to me.

After having gone through that phase, I still believe in God.

So if you've done your research and believe in rain doctors (or perhaps you are one), that's fine.

OdiliaRWynne said...

好多很有用資訊...感謝你的分享喔 ........................................

qust said...

It is no use crying over spilt milk...................................................

欣盈 said...

I do like ur article~!!!..................................................

長卉lisettec_buswell0606 said...

我們唯一需要恐懼的事,是恐懼本身........................................

逸凡逸凡 said...

xvideo打飛機專用網xvideos免費av影片A片洪爺免費85cc免費短片GOGO2聊天室77p2p免費短片洪爺色情片85cc A片go2 a片77p2p免費影片網洪爺貼圖區85cc線上看5278論壇77p2p線上看洪爺成人線上85cc免費看sogo色情77p2p免費看洪爺影城85cc影城go2影片77p2p影城洪爺色論壇85cc免費影片區go2免費影片77p2p免費影片區洪爺貼圖85cc影片區go2av影片77p2p影片區洪爺成年人網85cc成人片sogo成人77p2p成人片洪爺免費色情85cc觀看5278貼圖區77p2p觀看洪爺色情貼85cc影片5278影片網77p2p影片援交妹援交聊天室援交留言成人援交友辣妹野球拳辣妹露點

KarolR_Sundqui22855 said...

讓人流連忘返,真期待新文章發表!........................................

怡如 said...

thx rfor you sharing~~learn it by heart ........................................

roh0218_g said...

TAHNKS FOR YOUR SHARING~~~VERY NICE.................................................

蘇pet0701em_halvorsen said...

I do like ur article~!!!..................................................

家信 said...

朝著既定的目標走,就不會迷失。..................................................

TracyM瑞尹 said...

After a storm comes a calm..............................................

HaroldM22 said...

成人遊戲 視訊美女影音 高雄聊天聯盟 免費av1 g8mm視訊影音交友 日本女優貼圖 性感 av影片 做愛偷拍 聊天室 愛愛自拍 夫妻情趣 線上成人18 少女裸體貼圖 色情片影城 免付費a片 免費情色影片線上 免費色情影片網 一夜情的網站 一葉情貼圖片區 383 完美女人視訊聊天室 玩美女人美腿 屎尿美女 性感辣妹介紹 人妻聊天網 熟女做愛自拍 護士做愛 免費一對多 a圖分享區 舒舒 85cc成人片無碼 成人免費a片 嘟嘟 線上a片777 熟女貼圖 台灣援交妹影片 情人視訊聊天 偷拍鋼管秀 免費av電影 洪爺影成 大奶圖片 sex做愛影片 金瓶梅下載 日本巨乳美女 性愛自拍圖 後宮 限制級視訊 免費0204情色 免費性愛 比基尼走光

730A_ngelinaRabideau0 said...

世間是非,要如水泥地般水過則乾。..................................................

子ChristiLavigne11善 said...

Well done!............................................................

王周宏儒 said...

you look nice in that color!............................................................

振瑋 said...

愛,拆開來是心和受兩個字。用心去接受對方的一切,用心去愛對方的所有。..................................................................

皇銘 said...

blog is great~~祝你人氣高高~.................................................................

saas said...

幸福不是一切,人還有責任。....................................................................

陳芳 said...

希望能常常看到你的更新.................................................................